disassociated.com Flickr photos

Errors and excerpts excepted

Posted by John Lampard on Thursday, 24 July, 2008 to the comment subset

If you are quoting from a blog or forum post (as I do frequently) do you, or should you, correct spelling and grammar errors?

If the “error” was such that it significantly altered the context of the excerpt, then maybe I would. (And hope it wasn’t noticed?)

Would you contact the person who made the comments and get their ok to edit their words? Interesting question.

Take a passage signed by zipthwung, an astute online commenter: “pornography if for the ruling classes and their violent vulgar all consuming appetites. Or their slaves.” Interesting. But so as not to distract you with the typos, should I have repunctuated it, adding commas and plunking a hyphen into “all-consuming”? Should I have turned that “if” to “is”?

Tags: , , , , ,
Permalink | Contact | disassociated.com

Comments are welcome, please keep them relevant to the topic at hand. If you want to talk about something else, please contact me. Spam, SEO keyword "names", and crassness will not be tolerated.